The Moya View

Arguing with the Dead



Arguing With the Dead

Begin by calling her by name,
not the one etched on the granite monument in front of you,
not the one printed on the birth certificate—
that temporary name another mother
was forced to dream up
in the haze of post-labor fade,
in the ecstasy of seeing you
for the first time—

something that grew for nine months
inside this other,
and now rises before her,
a trembling presence—
each watching the other
in stunned awe, terror, joy, and fear—
in that time
when this other mother
still believed
in the goodness
of small things.

That name that became permanent
under the official seal,
that followed her around—
a shadow stitched to her name—
then detested,
outgrown,
a hand-me-down dress
that once fit her body
but never the feelings inside.

It is a name only she carries—
syllables folded into silence—
and you will never know it,
not even if you ask.

But one day,
in the hush of the kitchen,
as the kettle begins to sing
and the pasta water stirs with heat,
you will know it.

It will arrive
in the scent of cumin and soap—
a memory steeped in steam,
half prayer, half inheritance.

Later still,
when your child asks
a question you cannot answer,
she will laugh—
that laugh you feared,
the one too knowing,
too rehearsed,
too much like your own.

And there you know her truth—
that under this granite slab
she was not stone.
And as you reach down
to put a rose to her earth,
a pebble on her tombstone,
you feel the ache in your shoulders
from all the weight
she carried
for you.

Suddenly,
you are in her garden,
her hands in yours
showing you where
to plant the seed,
digging further to
feel the roots of
the living things
growing underneath—

telling you to finish
what she
never had
time
to grow.

For the first timein a long time—
you smile.
She is listening—
now.
She has learned
the cost
of her silence.

She has changed.
Not quickly. Not easily.
And in it
you hear the apology
she never spoke.
Feel the sadness
of letters written
but never sent.
The ones
you will find
crammed accidentally
behind the bills,
the lullabies
she wrote for you,
but never sung—
in the dark corners
of her writing desk—
when you return home
to settle her affairs.

You say to her stone:
You left me with too much.
She says:
I left you with what I had.
You say:
It wasn’t enough.
She says:
It was never meant to be—
this way.

You forgive her
not because she deserves it,
but because
legacy is not a ledger,
but a wound that wants
to be touched.

You feel it,
know it
now—
in the way you hold your child’s hand
when crossing the street—
in the pause—
before you speak
in anger—
in the softness
you swore you would
never inherit—
but have.

You know
now—
The dead are not cunning.
They are tired.
They are not liars.
They are just afraid.
They do not feast on shadow.
They make room for light.

You win the argument
not by proving them wrong,
but by living beyond
what they could imagine.
They do not vanish.
They become the better ending
they never wrote.

Comments

Leave a Reply

The Roses: Thorns in the Wallpaper
A Peach Seed Thrown Away

Discover more from The Moya View

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading