

There is Something deeply moving about a film that refuses to treat political activism as a distant chapter in history. Sian Heder’s *Being Heumann* brings urgency, anger, humor, and compassion to the disability rights movement, honoring a pivotal moment in American history that too rarely receives mainstream attention. Written by Heder and Rebekah Taussig and adapted from Judith Heumann’s 2020 memoir, the film recounts the 1977 occupation of the San Francisco Federal Building, when Heumann and more than one hundred fellow activists stood together to demand enforcement of Section 504 of the Rehabilitation Act.

The film’s greatest strength lies in its compassionate understanding that social progress rarely comes from powerful institutions alone. It is often won through the courage, persistence, and solidarity of people organizing together. Heder presents the occupation not simply as a protest, but as a sustained effort by people standing up to a government unwilling to act. Each roadblock tests the protesters’ resolve, while every bureaucratic excuse deepens their frustration and determination. The film carries a distinct agitprop sensibility, inviting viewers to consider who holds power and the struggle many face in seeking dignity.

Ruth Madeley delivers a moving and compelling performance as Judith Heumann, capturing the activist’s intelligence, strategic instincts, and unwavering determination with warmth and understanding. She portrays Heumann’s argumentative nature and impatience alongside her charisma and deep sense of purpose, allowing her rough edges to feel human rather than diminished. Madeley makes clear why others are drawn to Heumann’s leadership, even when they struggle with her methods.

What gives *Being Heumann* much of its energy, however, is the compassionate ensemble surrounding her. Madeline Delp’s Kitty Cone offers an essential counterbalance to Heumann’s approach, creating some of the film’s most compelling dramatic tensions. Michael Patrick Thornton brings warmth and dignity to disability pioneer Ed Roberts. Antwan Tolliver is especially moving as Brad Lomax, the Black Panther activist whose solidarity reflects the bonds that helped sustain the protest. Daniel Durant, Andrew Pilkington, Roberta Colindrez, Russell Harvard, and the rest of the cast make the movement feel deeply human—not simply a group of supporting characters orbiting a single protagonist.

The film thoughtfully portrays how disabled activists navigated challenges created by inaccessible institutions. One of its most poignant and gently humorous recurring details comes when authorities consider arresting demonstrators, only to discover that local jails lack wheelchair-accessible facilities. Moments like these reveal the painful absurdities of systemic inaccessibility while honoring the activists’ resilience. Heder recognizes that activism often calls for creativity, improvisation, and perseverance—not only solemn speeches.

The sit-in sequences are the film’s most affecting moments. As phone lines are cut, food supplies dwindle, and pressure from government officials intensifies, the protesters come together as a resourceful, deeply supportive community. The ensemble’s camaraderie feels genuine, and their victories offer a shared sense of hope. Their frustrations—and the strain they endure—are impossible to overlook.

Being Heumann falters in its effort to create a compelling central antagonist; Mark Ruffalo brings considerable presence and nuance to Joseph A. Califano Jr., Jimmy Carter’s Secretary of Health, Education, and Welfare, though the conflict between Califano and Heumann never fully takes hold. The screenplay returns often to their political standoff, but their dynamic feels more functional than emotionally resonant. Califano represents the institutional barriers Heumann faces, yet the film might have explored his character with greater depth and compassion.

The result is a conflict that can feel overly simplified. Government officials hesitate, protesters press for action, and the narrative returns to familiar versions of the same confrontation. Ruffalo gives a capable performance, but the character and relationship don’t have enough depth to add complexity to these scenes. For a film so committed to portraying political struggle, it could have developed its central political opponent with more care.

A major limitation lies in how Judith Heumann is portrayed. Although she is at the center of nearly every scene, the film sometimes leaves viewers with only a partial sense of who she was beyond her activism. We learn a great deal about her political goals, strategic insight, and leadership, but much less about her inner life, private fears, personal contradictions, and experiences beyond the movement—parts of her story that might have brought her more fully into view.

This absence feels all the more noticeable because the real Heumann was such a compelling figure. Viewers familiar with *Crip Camp: A Disability Revolution* may wish for a fuller, more personal portrait of the woman behind the organizing. The film honors her many accomplishments, but at times presents her more as a symbol than as a fully realized individual.

The screenplay’s good intentions are clear, though they can occasionally feel a little too pronounced. Some musical cues lean heavily into emotional moments, while a few exchanges of dialogue seem more focused on delivering lessons than revealing character. These choices don’t undermine the film, but they can soften its dramatic impact at times.

Yet Being Heumann finds its footing whenever it gives disabled people the space to speak for themselves. The congressional hearing scenes are especially moving. As activists share the discrimination they faced in education, employment, and public life, the rhetoric recedes, making room for their personal testimony. Their accounts of being denied opportunities, shut out of schools, or treated as safety hazards are painful and deeply affecting. The film allows these stories to speak for themselves, and their impact is unmistakable.

Heder’s direction remains grounded in accessibility and emotional clarity, guiding the story with care while keeping it moving and resisting excess sentimentality. She never loses sight of the profound stakes. The film makes Section 504’s implementation feel consequential not through legislative language alone, but by centering the people whose lives were at stake.

By the time the protesters celebrate Califano’s signing of Section 504 after nearly a month of occupation, their hard-won victory feels deeply deserved. The closing glimpse of the later struggle for the Americans with Disabilities Act underscores how progress is built over time, through countless acts of courage and resistance by people determined to challenge exclusion.

Being Heumann isn’t a flawless biographical drama. It softens some conflicts, occasionally leans into familiar message-movie territory, and leaves parts of Judith Heumann’s personality unexplored. Still, the film’s heart, conviction, humor, and remarkable disabled ensemble make its shortcomings easy to forgive. Above all, it honors the truth that rights are rarely granted freely; they are won through pressure, solidarity, and persistence.

That message gives *Being Heumann* its enduring power. While it may not fully capture the woman at its heart, it honors the movement she helped build—a meaningful achievement that makes the film worthy of celebration.

The B+. Apple TV +.






Leave a Reply