The thing about Practical Magic is that it behaves as if it woke up on a sugar bender, sprinted into a séance, tripped over a romance novel, and decided that was enough story structure for one lifetime. Griffin Dunne’s film barrels forward with a manic grin, and Sandra Bullock keeps the whole contraption from collapsing through sheer force of grounded presence. The movie is a good‑bad delight: unruly, shameless, and occasionally touching in ways it absolutely does not earn.
The film’s cottagecore production design is the real sorcery. The Owens house is a maximalist shrine to cozy witch aesthetics, and Dunne shoots it with the confidence of someone who knows the wallpaper is doing half the emotional labor. The greenhouse, the creaking floors, the kitchen that looks ready to swallow a mortal whole—these elements give the movie a tactile identity that outperforms its narrative discipline. The setting is the film’s spine, even when the plot forgets it has one.
Bullock and Nicole Kidman operate on opposite emotional frequencies, and the clash generates a jittery, irresistible energy. Bullock’s restraint keeps the movie from floating away, while Kidman’s feral exuberance keeps it from sitting still. Their chemistry is the film’s most coherent argument for itself. Every scene between them feels charged with a chaotic sibling logic that makes the movie’s tonal whiplash feel intentional, even when it clearly isn’t.
The film’s treatment of domestic violence is where its tonal chaos becomes a liability. Jimmy Angelov’s brutality is presented with genuine menace, then abruptly folded into the movie’s comic‑horror hijinks. The resurrection sequence is a carnival ride that shouldn’t be fun but undeniably is, and that dissonance creates a strange moral wobble. Dunne wants the danger to matter, but he also wants the audience to giggle at the absurdity of burying a serial killer in the garden. The result is a film that refuses to sit still long enough to earn its gravitas.
Still, the margarita‑fueled witch‑aunt chaos remains one of the great scenes of 90s studio comedy. Stockard Channing and Dianne Wiest deliver insults with the precision of seasoned assassins, and the whole sequence feels possessed by a giddy, unhinged spirit. It’s messy, but it’s the kind of mess that makes the movie feel alive. Dunne’s direction thrives when it leans into the unruly communal energy of women who have decided the night requires tequila and questionable decisions.
The film’s romantic arc is the least compelling ingredient. Aidan Quinn’s investigator arrives with the narrative function of a plot coupon, redeemable for closure and a kiss. Bullock sells the emotional beats, but the script treats the romance as a mandatory studio checkbox. The curse, the badge, the destiny talk—none of it lands with weight. It’s functional, but it’s also the part of the movie that feels most manufactured.
Where the movie succeeds is in its commitment to emotional sincerity, even when the story is sprinting in circles. Dunne’s direction embraces the absurdity of magic as a narrative device without pretending it’s metaphorically profound. The film’s heart lies in the messy, volatile bond between sisters who refuse to abandon each other, even when the universe keeps throwing supernatural nonsense at them. That emotional core is sturdy enough to survive the film’s tonal ricochets.
The final exorcism sequence is a carnival of camp, community theater energy, and triumphant broom‑waving. It’s ridiculous, but it’s also the moment the film finally commits to its own chaotic identity. The townspeople join the coven, the curse dissolves, and the movie lands on a note of communal acceptance that feels earned through sheer persistence. It’s not elegant, but it’s undeniably satisfying.
In the end, Practical Magic is a film that thrives because it refuses to behave. It’s a Halloween comfort watch that survives its plot holes through charm, chemistry, and unapologetic weirdness. It’s a good‑bad movie in the purest sense: flawed, frantic, and unforgettable.
Grade: B+. HBO MAX.
Leave a Reply