The Thursday Murder Club arrives not with a bang, but with a chuckle and a well-folded cardigan. Chris Columbus directs with a gentle hand, letting the film unfold— a retirement home newsletter—pleasant, occasionally poignant, and peppered with gossip. Helen Mirren leads the charge as Elizabeth Best, a retired spy whose gaze could still dismantle a government. Her plaid blazers are sharper than some of the film’s jokes, but she carries the weight of aging with grace and grit. The club’s weekly meetings are less about blood and more about belonging, and that’s where the film finds its pulse.
Pierce Brosnan’s Ron Ritchie stomps through Coopers Chase with unionist bravado, organizing protests and dodging aqua aerobics. Celia Imrie’s Joyce is a delight, her cakes and curiosity equally irresistible. Ben Kingsley’s Ibrahim, sadly, is given little to do but nod wisely and vanish into the background. The ensemble is charming, but unevenly served. Still, their chemistry bubbles— a forgotten kettle—warm, familiar, and slightly overboiled.
The murders themselves are less thrilling than the llamas. Yes, llamas. Emotional support animals that wander the grounds— furry metaphors for the absurdity of aging. The first death—a co-owner of the retirement home—is the spark that lights the disco flame. Joyce’s glee at a real case is infectious, even if the soundtrack’s sudden burst of “Disco Inferno” reeks of a prank pulled by the editor. The second murder adds tension, but not complexity. The mystery is serviceable, never gripping.
Where the film succeeds is in its quieter moments. Elizabeth’s husband, played with aching subtlety by Jonathan Pryce, drifts in and out of clarity. Dementia is handled with tenderness, not melodrama. His good days are gifts, his bad ones reminders. The film doesn’t dwell, but it doesn’t flinch either. Aging is not a punchline here—it’s a presence. The Thursday in the title becomes a ritual, a reckoning, a weekly dance with memory and mortality.
Chris Columbus directs with affection, though not always precision. Some scenes wobble, like Elizabeth’s bafflement at texting slang. It’s hard to believe this woman, who once infiltrated embassies, doesn’t know what “WTF” means. The joke lands with a thud, and the young mother’s reaction feels staged. These moments risk turning the characters into caricatures, but the film pulls back just in time, letting Mirren’s steel-eyed dignity restore balance.
The theme of aging is woven throughout, sometimes delicately, sometimes with a neon sign. Loneliness, legacy, and the fear of being forgotten haunt the corridors of Coopers Chase. The cemetery subplot, with its threatened demolition, becomes a metaphor for erasure. Ron’s protest is more than noise—it’s a refusal to be buried before the body gives out. The club’s investigations are acts of defiance, proof that relevance doesn’t expire with retirement.
The plot, while meandering, does enough to keep the llamas moving. It’s not a masterclass in mystery, but it doesn’t need to be. The joy lies in watching these seniors outwit the police, outmaneuver bureaucracy, and outlive expectation. Naomi Ackie and Daniel Mays provide comic relief, though their subplot feels almost a separate show. Still, their presence adds texture, even if the stitching is loose.
The film’s tone is a balancing act—part cozy crime, part elegy. It doesn’t always land its jokes, and the pacing occasionally drifts. But when it works, it works with heart. The Thursday Murder Club isn’t about solving death—it’s about surviving life. The club members aren’t detectives; they’re archivists of their own relevance, scribbling meaning into the margins of their golden years.
Helen Mirren anchors the film with elegance and bite. Her Elizabeth is not just a character—she’s a thesis on aging with agency. Imrie’s Joyce adds levity, Brosnan’s Ron adds fire, and Kingsley’s Ibrahim adds… well, he adds presence. The cast is in tune with the film’s vision, even when the script falters. Columbus directs with warmth, if not daring. The film doesn’t reinvent the genre, but it doesn’t embarrass it either.
In the end, “The Thursday Murder Club” is a gentle triumph. It stumbles, yes. It indulges, certainly. But it also listens—to memory, to grief, to the quiet thrill of being seen. It’s a film that understands that murder isn’t the point. Thursday is. The gathering, the ritual, the refusal to fade. That’s the mystery worth solving.
Grade: B+. Streaming on Netflix.
Leave a Reply