Sundance 2026: A Ribbon, a Rivalry, and a Song: Reviewing The Musical

Giselle Bonilla’s The Musical bursts onto the scene with infectious charm, mixing playful schoolyard antics with heartfelt melodies. The story follows a passionate, slightly restless playwright and middle school theater teacher, portrayed with vibrant energy by Nevada Jose. His world turns upside down when he discovers his ex-girlfriend is now dating his lifelong rival—the school principal. Bonilla masterfully weaves humor, longing, and ambition into a delightful tapestry, making the narrative both lively and emotionally resonant.

Nevada Jose lights up the film with a performance brimming with energy and vulnerability. His character’s quest for artistic recognition and emotional healing injects the story with vitality, especially as he devises a plan to thwart the principal’s chase for the prestigious Blue Ribbon of Academic Excellence. Rob Lowe adds a sleek, charismatic touch to the role of the principal, serving as both a foil and an unlikely source of inspiration. Gillian Jacobs, portraying the ex-girlfriend torn between lingering affection and new possibilities, brings warmth and lucidity to every scene she inhabits.

Alexander Heller’s script dives deep into the vibrant spirit of musical theater, infusing the school halls with lively songs that vividly unveil the characters’ inner worlds. The playful rivalry between the teacher and principal blossoms with theatrical flair, each scheme choreographed like an awaiting cue in a grand performance. Bonilla’s direction amplifies this dynamic rhythm, infusing the film with a lively energy that perfectly captures the exhilarating chaos of a school production.

As the story unfolds, the film delves into the teacher’s profound desire for artistic fulfillment. His attempts to hinder the principal’s Blue Ribbon campaign unexpectedly foster genuine connections, particularly with students who turn to him for support. These moments stand out as some of the film’s most heartfelt scenes, capturing a man ignited anew by his love for teaching and the thrill of creative collaboration.

As the story unfolds, Rob Lowe’s principal transforms from merely a rival into a compelling obstacle. His dreams, fueled by years of relentless pursuit of recognition, add a surprising emotional depth. Jacobs’ character skillfully connects the two men, serving as a poignant reminder that ambition and love can coexist without compromising each other.

By the final act, The Musical transforms into a vibrant celebration of collaboration, forgiveness, and the unpredictable magic of school theater. Bonilla’s inspired direction, combined with energetic performances from Jose, Lowe, and Jacobs, breathes life into a film that resonates with genuine emotion. While the Blue Ribbon serves as the initial spark, the true reward lies in rediscovering purpose, community, and the pure joy of creating something memorable together.

Letter Grade: B+.